PLEASE SUPPORT W42ST
W42ST runs on limited resources to keep Hell’s Kitchen connected, updated and upbeat. Access is totally free. Please consider supporting what we do so that we can continue our work!
Chez Napoleon — the oldest French restaurant in the city — may be forced to close permanently after a Con Edison Smart Meter conversion led city officials to shut off their gas in early December. Nine weeks later, the Hell’s Kitchen eatery is still shuttered.
The family-run restaurant on W50th Street just east of 9th Avenue, open since 1960 and operated by the Bruno family from 1982, was unexpectedly shuttered in early December 2021 after Con Edison representatives inspecting their newly installed Smart Meters detected an unusual smell and turned off gas services. William Welles, co-owner and son of co-owner Elayne Bruno, says the smell wasn’t from a gas leak but rather an oil-based paint recently applied to the ground floor of the building. “Usually Con Ed has some sort of meter where you go around and you see where a leak is coming from — he just was going by his sense of smell,” says Welles. “So it smelled like a little bit of gas and nobody could tell us where this gas leak was.” Whatever the source, the smell led Con Edison to shut down operations and request new pipes for the building.
“Somebody came in, took measurements with an architect. Then we had somebody with a clipboard show up, also did something, and now it’s like, we’re just waiting for the Department of Buildings (DOB) to give the license for the work order,” said Welles. Chez Napoleon joins the unfortunate ranks of other New York food institutions that have been shuttered by the DOB, some of which never reopened.
The closure was a major blow to Chez Napoleon and the Bruno family, who were hoping for a strong holiday season and the chance to celebrate their 60th year after lengthy COVID-19 shutdowns and a lack of pre-Broadway crowds. “We couldn’t have a proper 60th anniversary because we were shut down with COVID. We lost all of the Christmas people, and then now January and February — I mean it’s slim out there, you know?” says Welles.
The uncertainty has hit his mother, co-owner Elayne Bruno, particularly hard. She has been involved with Chez Napoleon since working there as a waitress under the original ownership, eventually purchasing the restaurant with her mother, Chef ‘Grandmere’ Marguerite Bruno in 1982. Welles and Bruno have kept the spirit of Chez Napoleon alive for 40 years, serving hyper-traditional dishes developed from Marguerite’s own time-honored recipes. Now in her mid-seventies, Elayne “can’t sleep at night,” says Welles. “We got the PPP and the grant and all that, but now that’s been pissed away, because in the last six months we’ve lost like $200,000 — and that’s gone from the aid money from COVID.”
The co-owners are also concerned about the impact of perpetual closures on their team — “My employees, we had to put them on unemployment again, and we have a great team back there, but if worse comes to worst, they might wanna look elsewhere for jobs,” says Welles. Added to that, “retraining a new chef with my grandmother’s recipes” would be an additional hurdle.
The Bruno family’s recipes and a long-standing convivial crowd of regulars have kept Hell’s Kitchen residents flocking to Chez Napoleon for decades, landing amongst W42ST readers as a neighborhood “institution” for decadent, traditional French fare. Said Ross Avant in a recent West Side Story profile, “Intimate, and beautifully bedecked, it instantly transports you to Paris. And the food is absolutely sumptuous.” Chez Napoleon has taken sumptuousness as a de rigeur philosophy, serving up dishes rich with traditional French ingredients like butter, cream, and garlic and proudly declaring: “Amenz votre appétit en tant qu’invité’, mais laissez votre régime à la maison,” or — “Bring your appetite as a guest, but leave your diet at home.”
Chez Napoleon held the title of oldest French restaurant in NYC for three months before the shut down. “If we were open, it’d be still the oldest French restaurant, because Tout Va Bien went during the pandemic, and Le Veau D’or, which was the oldest one — that’s been under construction — they’ve been closed for more than three years even before the pandemic, and that was the oldest from the 1930s, so we’re now the oldest restaurant,” says Welles.
Welles is acutely aware of this legacy, and hopes that the DOB’s red tape won’t waylay them into a permanent closure. “I understand now, with what happened with the Bronx fire and the gas leaks and all that, they want to be extra cautious and everything, but I mean, it’s gonna be losing — I’m not saying we’re a landmark or an icon, but we kind of are, in a way, and with all of the restaurants shutting down one by one in this area — to lose one more … we’re now the oldest French restaurant,” says Welles.
Con Edison spokesperson Alfonso Quiroz spoke to W42ST and noted that the status of this particular case is with the energy services team: “The way the process normally goes is — if there’s a gas leak, we turn off the gas for safety’s sake. Then the landlord’s plumber would be responsible for any and all repairs. Once repairs are completed and the customer gets in touch, we turn services back on right away.” Chez Napoleon is currently awaiting updates from the Department of Buildings on the timeline of their pipe repair.
Welles and Bruno have been in contact with Council Member Erik Bottcher’s office, who in turn contacted the DOB in hopes of pushing the timeline of the work order. For now, Welles is holding out hope for an update and focusing on his other business, Wolfman Snax Beef Jerky.
“It’s just trying to get the work done, and then having us back up — ’cause then I would like to try to get like a real push of marketing, saying that we’re the oldest one, to make sure the people that know that we’re still alive.” Here’s hoping the city can come through so that regulars can once again exclaim Vive Chez Napoléon!
UPDATE 2/16/2022: W42ST heard back from Andrew Rudansky, Press Secretary for the Department of Buildings on the situation at Chez Napoleon. Says Rudansky — “The owners of this restaurant are not waiting on DOB for repairs. Our records indicate that they are waiting on the registered design professionals they hired, who has not taken the required steps to obtain work permits from DOB.”
Rudansky noted that in general, the DOB needs a paperwork from a Professionally Certified plumber to assign a work permit for gas repairs — which usually takes 1 day to process (unless the plumber already has Professional Certification privileges, in which case permits are awarded immediately). Once a permit is awarded and repairs are finished, the DOB must inspect the gas plumbing before granting a Gas Authorization order to turn services back on. This process usually takes about 3 days to complete.
In regards to Chez Napoleon, Rudansky says: “Our records show while the owner’s engineer filed the initial application notification with us online [on 2/3/22], they never filed any of the required paperwork items needed to get them the Professional Certification approval. Among the missing documentation that they have not yet submitted is the scope of work for the job, and the actual plans for the work. Once their design professional files the required items online, they will get their approval right away because they filed ‘Pro Cert.’ At that point they can obtain the required work permit, and the owner’s Licensed Master Plumber can perform the repairs.”
Rudanksy also notes that in the case of emergency gas leaks, the “Dept. has a separate Emergency Work Notification (EWN) process. Through the EWN process, there is literally zero wait time for the gas to be restored that can be attributable to DOB” as the EWN allows plumbers to make repairs right away and file necessary DOB paperwork after services are restored and the business is reopened.
We will update regarding situation at Chez Napoleon as information becomes available.
Charming, authentic warhorse of a restaurant. Ps Not sure if they are the oldest, as compared to Le Veau d’Or (which has yet to reopen)? Maybe they could claim title of “Oldest French Restaurant still operating” (despite the recent DOB hiccups)?
Ugh this is so sad. we are down 2 good / homey french restaurants in HK. 🙁
I hope Chez Napolean reopens…..I would love to go back. My first job out of college in 1982 was at 1633 Broadway and Chez Napolean was a go to eatery for our company. Best of luck to Chez Napolean!
Oh noooooo. And it’s peak Cassoulet season! Grrrrr
Thats so tough:(
A family business surviving all these years + covid just to be closed down now waiting on DOB to get it together?? Thats a disgrace. I hope they open soon. I’ll be the first one in to support them.
Tout va bien opened 1948
Tout Va Bien has not been open in over a year.
Come back, come back, Chez Napoleon. How can we get the DOB to do whatever is necessary to re-open our favorite French restaurant?
This is a great place and it needs to reopen asap!
Such a loss if it can’t come back. A wonderful NYC institution. A favorite of mine for decades
My favorite French restaurant in NYC completely authentic. Always great to get in there after the theater crowd, so quaint.
Please re-open because your ambience and food are equally formidable!
Our sense of loss grows each day. Can this be happening? All the years and now this.
This is terrible!! So unfair. William do you have an email for yourself or someone else so that we can assist in pressing Con Ed and the City to get this done?
We live in Wisconsin and are devastated by this news. We always dine at this historic restaurant with excellent cuisine and cozy ambiance when visiting NYC. We’re thinking of you often and hope for a positive resolution so that we can visit you again in the future.
UNBELIEVABLE! Have you notified “7 On Your Side” – ABC tv?
@Dale Christensen It’s very simple. Get the gas leak fixed with a licensed plumber.
Now this most likely not cheap if the buildings needs repiping .
The DOB in this case is just looking out for your safety as they don’y want you to blow up while you dine there.
What you could do to help is set up a “gofundme” page that they can pay for the repairs.
I grew up on W. 55th Street, and have been eating there since I was a young child, shortly after the restaurant first opened. What can we do to help them? I’d be happy to contribute through a “Go Fund Me” page if the family wants to set one up.
So now it’s almost mid-March and the threat to close still leads on the Chez Napoleon website. I’m dying to eat there again!
Aren’t new restaurants in NYC to be blocked from gas hookups?
I don’t live in the City, but frequent this FINE real FRENCH restaurant, it really doesn’t matter who is the oldest, its about real, and this establishment is REAL. heading to NYC next month and saddened that I cant take a special friend there, so they could enjoy something that is truly rare today
I’m rather disgusted at the City’s cavalier attitude toward this fine, historic restaurant’s horrific inability to get their gas leak problems resolved. The paperwork and bureaucratic stumbling is overwhelming and must be alleviated. The City must offer a helping hand to this gem.
This is all bullshit for the DOB…Con ED…
I am a GC and working with my plumber, engineers, architects… on a restaurant… no gas smell, an inspection for C of O two years later and thousands of dollars… multiple amendments for nothing… we past inspections.. Then shutting off gas for the rest of the residents above, just because.. this is a crime.. they are killing people.. just get a bulldozer and run over NYC… build a parking lot… its horrible.
Leave a comment